Best Substitutes for Witch Hazel

Best Substitutes for Witch Hazel

Natural is always better especially when we talk about skin-care ingredients. Remember your granny using witch hazel for various helpful health reasons. Well, now it’s your turn to repeat the same rituals, but today it’s pretty hard to find the same quality witch hazel so in this article, we will explore some amazing substitutes for witch hazel.    

Why Do We Need Witch Hazel Alternatives?

Witch hazel is naturally derived from a flowering plant (Hamamelis virginiana) that is mainly found in North America and Japan.

Witch hazel has always been a hot ingredient to store at home for quick and helpful relief from sudden health concerns.

From toners, lotions, cleansers, room sprays, ointments to shaving products, witch hazel is one of the best natural astringents today. Yes, people are again realizing the benefits of witch hazel and the wonders it works.

Many people who prefer natural ingredients for their skin consider witch hazel a very essential part of a skin-care routine.

Many of them are men who love witch hazel as the best aftershave to have in their grooming regimen. Unfortunately, there’s an extremely short supply of witch hazel these days. In addition, if you leave the bottle sitting long enough, your witch hazel can expire

From grocery stores, pharmacies, medical labs, Walmart, people find it really difficult to buy witch hazel with the same effectiveness and price.

No worries, you can use these below-mentioned alternatives for witch hazel with getting ensured of same effectiveness.   

What Can I Use Instead of Witch Hazel?   

1. Slippery Elm 

It is a native shrub of Central America that is well-known for its numerous topical health benefits. slippery elm witch hazel alternative

Slippery elm is a tried and tested herbal skin remedy that offers relief to a lot of skin ailments when chewed or consumed with water.

Unlike witch hazel, it might taste a little bitter and have a thick consistency because of its special astringent properties.    

Bestseller No. 1
Nature's Answer Slippery Elm | Super Concentrated Herbal Supplement |...
643 Reviews
Nature's Answer Slippery Elm | Super Concentrated Herbal Supplement |...
  • PREMIUM QUALITY: Slippery elm (Ulmus rubra) a.ka. red elm, soft elm, or Indian elm, is a...
  • EXCEPTIONAL FEATURES: Bio-chelated and Holistically Balanced. Bio Chelated and Kosher. Made from...
  • PERFECT CHOICE: Slippery Elm Capsules contain dried Slippery Elm in a hard capsule shell to maintain...
Bestseller No. 2
Slippery Elm Tincture - Organic Ulmus Rubra Liquid Supplement - Herbal...
  • ✅ SORT OUT YOUR STOMACH - Look after your upset gut with this slippery elm liquid supplement. Our...
  • ✅ SOOTHE YOUR THROAT - Slippery elm is a source of the soluble fiber mucilage. This substance...
  • ✅ KEEP YOUR WEIGHT IN CHECK - The Ulmus rubra in our slippery elm drops is a diuretic and may help...

You can use it in different forms but using Slippery Elm in a crushed powder form and dissolving it with your daily tea does magic to the body.

However, make sure you add a little amount of slippery elm when diluting it with water, and don’t let the mixture sit for too long. You can also add sweetness by using honey or jagger to make the drink a treat to your taste buds every time you consume it.   

2. Apple Cider Vinegar   

Apple cider vinegar has been used for years to treat various health concerns due to its special antimicrobial and health benefits.

apple cider vinegar substitute to witch hazel

From treating skin burn, acne, eczema, to protecting your skin from every harmful skin breakdown, it serves as an essential element to keep skin healthy, refreshed, and protected.

Not only apple cider vinegar is a very common kitchen ingredient used extensively in cooking, but many people also apply it before leaving the house.    

Bestseller No. 1
Bragg Organic Apple Cider Vinegar With the Mother– USDA Certified...
29,758 Reviews
Bragg Organic Apple Cider Vinegar With the Mother– USDA Certified...
  • BRAGG APPLE CIDER VINEGAR: The Bragg ACV Vinegar is made from organically grown apples, and offers...
  • ORGANIC INGREDIENTS: The Bragg ACV is raw, unfiltered, and crafted from organically grown apples. It...
  • MOTHER OF VINEGAR: The ‘Mother’ consists of strands of proteins, enzymes, and friendly bacteria...
SaleBestseller No. 2
Heinz Apple Cider Vinegar (1 Gallon)
  • Heinz Apple Cider Vinegar 1 Gallon Jug (128 Fl Oz)
  • Made with fine quality apples and crystal clear water Heinz vinegar is guaranteed at 5% acidity
  • Clean, mellow flavor, Heinz Apple Cider Vinegar is the mother of all vinegars and ideal for your...

You may use this powerful alternative to witch hazel as toners, cleansers, makeup removers, aftershave, and whatnot.

However, it’s normal to get irritated with the strong acidic smell it contains but diluting it with some water is always a better option.

Simply soak a cotton ball in it and press on the affected skin area for a few seconds. This will offer relief from the burning sensation on the skin.   

3. Rose Water

Rose Water is one of the best and natural witch hazel alternatives that you can use without any worry. It is one of those very rare effective skin-care ingredients that doesn’t have any immediate side-effect on using every day. rose water witch hazel alternative

Being extremely soothing and mildly astringent, rose water should be your first go-to help in case of any skin problem.    

It has been used for years in the skin-care regimen of men and women both and has shown incredible difference on the skin. With emitting a pleasant fragrance on applying, rose water contains anti-inflammatory properties to treat every kind of skin irritation.

A lot of men spray rose water on their face before and after shaving to prep the skin for contact with razor blades and possible cuts and nicks.

Bestseller No. 2
Method Foaming Hand Wash, Rose Water, 10 oz, 6 pack, Packaging May...
  • Contains (6) 10 ounce bottles of foaming hand soap
  • Foaming hand wash with plant-based cleansers
  • Biodegradable formula made without parabens or phthalates.

Try to avoid buying rose water from the market unless you have to, instead make one safely at home by distilling rose petals with steam for a few minutes. Once chilled, store it in an air-tight container and keep it in the fridge for safe use for up to 30 days.   

4. Cucumber Juice

Cucumber is a common ingredient to use while making a variety of skin DIY’s. But, did you know that cucumber juice is an excellent alternative to witch hazel for an array of skincare benefits? Cucumber Juice instead of witch hazel

Whether you start your day with a fresh cucumber juice or spray it as a skin-toner, it has magical health benefits for both your skin and body.

It keeps your skin hydrated, refreshed, free from skin diseases, and does wonders in weight loss plus preventing cancer like witch hazel.    

Also, using cotton pads soaked in cucumber juice is a widely proven remedy for severe dark circles and puffy eyes.

Bestseller No. 1
O2 Living Juice Green Vitality Organic Cold-Pressed, No Sugar or Water...
16 Reviews
O2 Living Juice Green Vitality Organic Cold-Pressed, No Sugar or Water...
  • ⭐⭐⭐NEW YORK CUSTOMERS: Select Two-Day Delivery when making your purchase. Since we operate out...
  • GREEN VITALITY: Packed with fresh, organic green vegetables, Green Vitality provides a powerful...
  • COLD-PRESSED: As the name suggests, fresh vegetables and fruits are “pressed” so the maximum...
Bestseller No. 2
O2 Living Juice Green Vitality Organic Cold-Pressed Shot, No Sugar or...
28 Reviews
O2 Living Juice Green Vitality Organic Cold-Pressed Shot, No Sugar or...
  • ⭐⭐⭐NEW YORK CUSTOMERS: Select Two-Day Delivery when making your purchase. Since we operate out...
  • GREEN VITALITY: Packed with fresh, organic green vegetables, Green Vitality provides a powerful...
  • COLD-PRESSED: As the name suggests, fresh vegetables and fruits are “pressed” so the maximum...

Its anti-aging properties also work like magic by reducing the appearance of wrinkles, fine lines, and declining beauty.

The presence of skincare ingredients like vitamin C, silica, caffeic acid in cucumber juice closes the skin pores to prevent fungal infections from entering the skin.    

5. Rubbing Alcohol   

Also known as isopropyl alcohol, this incredible alternative for witch hazel is a must-to-have ingredient in your skin-care products for a myriad of helpful uses.

Bestseller No. 2
PANA 7 Oz Professional Alcohol-Labeled Push Down Liquid Pumping Empty...
  • Capacity: 7 Ounces
  • Polyethylene Empty Bottle with Alcohol Labeled
  • Convenient Swing Lid, Reduces Odors and Maintains Purity

It works as an extremely effective astringent that keeps all the harmful bacteria and germs at bay and fights harmful skin infections.

Due to its volatile nature and anti-bacterial properties, rubbing alcohol is extensively used in deodorants, perfumes, after-shave, and many liquid-based skin-ointments. 

Can Rubbing Alcohol Substitute For Witch Hazel?

Yes, rubbing alcohol is an excellent substitute for witch hazel. Rubbing alcohol is a good astringent for cuts and scrapes.

Can Witch Hazel Replace Rubbing Alcohol?   

Yes, both witch hazel and rubbing alcohol can replace each other due to similar antiseptic properties and healthy skin benefits. Many people also, can rubbing alcohol substitute for witch hazel? This answer here is also yes. 

Like witch hazel, rubbing alcohol is also a credible natural bactericidal treatment and can provide resistance from every strong to weak bacteria, fungus, and viruses. Either you use rubbing alcohol or witch hazel, both can help you with numerous skin diseases including eczema, acne, and rosacea.

Rubbing alcohol can easily be found in drug stores as a weak acid and should always be applied in minimal quantity. Don’t forget to instantly apply any moisturizer after using rubbing alcohol as it can cause dryness to your skin while leaving it chapped or cracked.    


It’s pointless to wait for witch hazel to restock or pay high prices to any dealer when you can use these incredible alternatives for witch hazel. All the mentioned ingredients contain remarkable health benefits and are easily accessible to use for any skin problem without worry. In case you feel any allergy or irritation, instantly stop using the ingredient and seek help from any dermatologist.